Casper SitesBlog

How To Choose A Web Designer For Your Small Business.

Sean, the web designer behind Casper SitesBy Sean, Casper Sites4 min readUpdated November 17, 2026

To choose a web designer, ask other business owners who they used, look at sites the designer has made on your phone, get a fixed price in writing, and see something for your business before you pay. Skip anybody who promises you page one or pressures you to sign today.

That’s the short version. Here’s how I’d go about it if I were in your shoes, step by step.

Where do I find a web designer?

Start with people you already know. Ask other business owners who built their site and whether they’d use them again. A name that comes with a story is worth more than any ad.

After that, search Google for a web designer in your town and read the reviews. Reviews from small businesses like yours tell you more than a big list of logos.

One place not to start: the cold call. If someone calls saying they’re with Google and can get you to the top, hang up. Google’s own help page says it will never call to “guarantee you a special spot,” and Google’s warning about those calls is worth a read.

Should I hire a freelancer, an agency or build it myself?

For most small service businesses, a freelancer is the sweet spot. You pay less than an agency and you talk to the person actually building your site.

Here’s how the three usually shake out:

  • An agency has a team, a process and a bigger price. That makes sense if you need a big site, ads and marketing all in one place.
  • A freelancer is one person. You get them directly, and the price is usually lower. The tradeoff is that it all rests on one person, so make sure you know who owns your website once it’s built.
  • Doing it yourself on a website builder costs the least money and the most time. If you like that kind of thing, go for it. If you’d rather be working, it’s usually not a good trade.

Does it matter if my web designer is local?

It’s not required, but it helps. Someone local knows your towns, can meet you for coffee and understands who you’re trying to reach.

What matters more is whether they answer. A designer across the country who calls you back the same day beats one down the street who takes a week.

I’m a local web designer here in Chandler, so I’m a little biased on this one. But I’d still tell you to pick the one who answers.

What should I look for in their work?

Look for sites that are clear, not fancy. Open a few of their sites on your phone and ask yourself if you can tell in a few seconds what the business does, where it works and how to call.

That’s the test your own customers will use. Most of them won’t care about the design. They’ll care whether they can find your number before they lose interest.

Also check that the sites load fast and look right on a phone. If a designer’s own work is slow or hard to use on your phone, yours probably will be too.

How do I compare quotes from different web designers?

Compare what you get for the whole first year, not just the build price. Two quotes that look $500 apart can end up being the same, or one can cost twice as much once the monthly fees are in.

Ask each designer to put it in writing: how many pages, who writes the words, what the monthly fee covers and what extra pages cost later. Then you’re comparing the same thing.

I put a list of questions to ask any web designer in its own post, so you can bring the same questions to every call.

What are the red flags when hiring a web designer?

The biggest red flags are a promise of page one, pressure to sign today, no written price and a lot of tech talk you can’t follow.

  • ”Guaranteed page one.” Nobody can promise that. Walk away.
  • ”This price is only good today.” A good designer will still be there tomorrow.
  • No fixed price in writing. If they won’t write it down, it’s going to change.
  • They can’t explain things in plain words. If you can’t understand them now, it won’t get easier after you’ve paid.
  • They want you to write the whole site. That’s where a lot of projects stall.

How do I know if a web designer is the right fit?

Ask them to show you something for your business before you pay. If they’ll mock up your homepage first, you’ll know pretty quickly if you’re on the same page.

That’s how I do it. You get a free mockup of your homepage first. If you like it, we keep going. If you don’t, you don’t owe me anything.

How long should it take to choose a web designer?

A week or two is plenty. Talk to two or three designers, get their prices in writing and pick the one you trust most.

Don’t overthink it, but don’t rush it either. The right designer won’t mind you taking a few days. And if someone gets pushy about it, that’s your answer.

Sean, the web designer behind Casper Sites

Written by Sean. I build websites for small service businesses from Chandler, Arizona. I write these to answer the questions owners actually ask, in plain words. Here’s what I charge for a website.

Free 15 minute call

Get Your Free Homepage Mockup.

Leave your info and I’ll get right back to you within the hour.

Reach me by:

No spam and no contract. I only use this to get back to you.